Skip to content

Observatory ProtocolOpen developmentGovernance

Governance and decisions

Who decides what about the protocol, how a decision is recorded, and the rules that keep it neutral and open.

Version
0.1.0-draft
Status
Draft specification
Specification
CC BY 4.0
Code
Apache-2.0
Steward
GCRI Canada
Source
obsp-0.1-foundation

Bodies and decisions

The bodies that maintain the specification, how a change is decided and how releases are made. (Observatory Protocol, Governance)

The charter (CHARTER.md) sets the mission, stewardship and principles. This document sets who does what and how a change is decided. The rules are in policies/governance.md.

Bodies

BodyWhoDoes
SecretariatGCRI Canada, lead institution and steward for the Nexus ConsortiumRuns the repository, gateways, calendar and records; publishes releases; routes contributions; holds the name and release keys in trust
EditorsAppointed by the Secretariat on the Consortium's behalf from active contributors; recuse on their own proposalsHold the pen on the specification and registers; review and merge; dispose of comments with reasons
Conformance reviewersAppointed like the editors, independent of the claim under reviewRerun the suite on submitted evidence; list or refuse claims
Security responseEditors named in MAINTAINERS.mdHandle private vulnerability reports
Nexus Standards bodiesGlobal Standards Council, technical committee TC-SYS, working groups WG-DEV and WG-CNFDecide normative changes under NS-13 once constituted; until then the Secretariat runs the interim procedure below

The Global Risks Forum and The Global Risks Alliance take part in review, dialogue and adoption through their gateways and through their seats in the Nexus Standards bodies.

Change process: Observatory Improvement Proposals

StageWhat happensMinimum time
DRAFTAn OIP is opened as a pull request from oips/0000-template.md
REVIEWEditors, implementers and anyone else comment; the OIP names the sections, schemas, fixtures, conformance cases and registers it changes
LAST_CALLPublic comment window, announced on the Nexus Standards site90 days for a new function or profile; 30 days for a revision, register or policy change; 14 days for errata
ACCEPTEDMerged when every comment has a disposition and every check passes; the same pull request updates the specification, schemas with positive and negative fixtures, conformance cases, registers and CHANGELOG.md
IMPLEMENTEDAt least one implementation in IMPLEMENTATIONS.md shows the change at SELF_TESTED or higher

An OIP may be WITHDRAWN at any stage. Editorial fixes such as typos and broken links need no OIP. A security fix may take an expedited OIP (SEC-2).

Interim procedure. Until the Global Standards Council charters the protocol's working group, the editors decide by consensus on the public record. The Secretariat confirms ACCEPTED. Any participant may appeal a process decision to the Secretariat (GOV-5).

Versions and releases

See policies/versioning.md, policies/deprecation.md and docs/guides/releasing.md.

Licences and contributions

ItemTerms
Specification, schemas, registers, policies, documentationCC-BY-4.0
Tools, SDK, conformance suiteApache-2.0
ContributionsSame licences; Developer Certificate of Origin sign-off on each commit (PAR-3)
PatentsContributors disclose known essential claims and license them royalty-free to conforming implementations (IPR-2, IPR-3)
The protocol nameUsed only to state a claim that meets policies/conformance-claims.md (CNF-5)

File-level licences are recorded in REUSE.toml.

Governance and decisions

Who decides what about the protocol, and how a decision is recorded. (Observatory Protocol policy, Governance and decisions)

GOV-1
GCRI Canada is the lead institution and steward of the protocol for the Nexus Consortium and runs the Secretariat; it holds the repository, the names and the release keys in trust for the Consortium.
GOV-2
Technical decisions are taken by the editors on the public record after review and, for normative changes, through the Nexus Standards development process (NS-13). Consensus comes first; votes happen only after consensus fails.
GOV-3
No organisation, sponsor, provider or operator holds a veto or a reserved seat on technical decisions because of funding, hosting or infrastructure.
GOV-4
Every decision is a public record with its reasons, the comments received and their disposition, except undisclosed vulnerabilities and personal matters.
GOV-5
A process decision can be appealed to the Secretariat and, once constituted, to the appeals body of the Nexus Standards programme.

Neutrality

Keep the protocol usable by every operator and free of commercial capture. (Observatory Protocol policy, Neutrality)

NEU-1
The specification, schemas and registers name roles, never organisations, products, vendors or endpoints.
NEU-2
No contribution may promote a company, product or paid service; requirements name capabilities, never vendors.
NEU-3
Every external dependency of a conforming deployment is replaceable behind a typed contract with a tested exit path (principle P6).
NEU-4
Consortium systems that implement the protocol hold no privileged role in it; any operator can replace any of them.
NEU-5
The repository check (tools/validate.py, group neutrality) runs on every change and fails on a denied term.

Intellectual property and licences

The terms on which the protocol is open to everyone. (Observatory Protocol policy, Intellectual property and licences)

IPR-1
The specification, schemas, registers, policies and documentation are licensed CC-BY-4.0; tools, SDK and conformance suite are licensed Apache-2.0 (REUSE.toml).
IPR-2
Contributors license their contributions under the same licences and disclose any patent claim they know to be essential to a draft.
IPR-3
Contributors commit to license essential patent claims royalty-free to every conforming implementation.
IPR-4
Implementing the protocol requires no fee, membership, account or permission.

References

Sources cited on this page, in order of first citation. Addresses were last checked on the date shown.

  1. Observatory Protocol, Governance: GOVERNANCE.md Observatory Protocol 0.1 (draft), CC BY 4.0.
  2. Observatory Protocol policy, Governance and decisions: registers/policies.yaml governance Observatory Protocol 0.1 (draft), CC BY 4.0.
  3. Observatory Protocol policy, Neutrality: registers/policies.yaml neutrality Observatory Protocol 0.1 (draft), CC BY 4.0.
  4. Observatory Protocol policy, Intellectual property and licences: registers/policies.yaml ipr-and-licensing Observatory Protocol 0.1 (draft), CC BY 4.0.